We begin with the job, not the business
Every list at Best Columbus answers one request a Columbus household or company might type into a phone, such as who replaces windows or who treats a sprained ankle. A business gets onto that list only when the request describes its regular work. A window specialist sits above a remodeler whose site mentions windows in a long menu.
That is why we keep lists short, at most ten names, and why we leave out businesses that merely sit near a topic.
Years of public record outweigh one good month
We read what customers have said in public about each business and look for a pattern across several years. A run of praise that started last spring tells us less than steady, unremarkable good reports over a long stretch. We read for substance: did the crew come on the day it promised, did the final bill resemble the estimate, and how did the owner handle a mistake.
What a business says for itself counts too
A website that lists the jobs it takes, the suburbs it drives to, how it prices and the licenses or trade groups it holds makes comparison easier for you, so it counts in a business's favor. Silence about any of that does not rule a business out, but it does leave a gap that other businesses on the list fill.
Money buys a label and never a place
Being listed is free. Only a business already listed may buy Pro, an extended page carrying phone, site, pictures and promotions that leaves its place untouched, or Top, a seat among the first three places of that list, shown under a label that says so. Neither plan can bring a business onto a list, and neither affects what we write about it.
What we do with the data guides
The three guides in this section run on the City of Columbus's own open files and on a guide from Ohio's Division of Industrial Compliance. Each guide shows the date we last checked it. The communities map places our businesses by the coordinates of their addresses, so counts describe our lists and not the whole city. The permit pages count permits in the city's file and say what that file cannot tell you. When a source changes its layout or its rules, we rebuild the page and change the date.
Telling us we got it wrong
Shops shut, relocate and take on new work. Send a note to info@bestcolumbus.us naming the business and the page where you noticed the problem, and an editor will look into it. A business owner who has claimed a page can also correct its hours, services, description and photo directly. A place on a list is a good place to start and no guarantee, so confirm licenses, insurance and written estimates before work begins.
The Best Columbus editorial team